Email Us [email protected]
some words about us
Welcome!
Welcome to the Key Lantern Motel and Blue Fin Inn—your original mom-and-pop place to stay in Islamorada, Florida Keys. For over 30 years, we’ve proudly offered clean, affordable accommodations in the heart of the Keys, just steps from world-class fishing spots, local restaurants, and beautiful beaches.
Owned and operated by longtime local Deb Gillis, our motel isn’t about bells and whistles—it’s about staying true to the easygoing, barefoot spirit of the Keys. Deb and her family have poured their heart into keeping this place authentic, friendly, and genuinely “keezy”, where you feel like you’re staying with neighbors, not a corporation.
Consistently High Guest Satisfaction Since 1993
We’re not fancy—but we’re real. And that’s exactly how we like it.
Whether you’re road-tripping through the Keys, planning a fishing getaway, or just looking for a laid-back, budget-friendly place to stay in Islamorada, you’ll find a comfortable bed, a great location, and a warm welcome here.
Come as you are, kick off your flip-flops, and experience the charm of one of the last truly local places to stay in the Florida Keys.
top reasons to choose Key Lantern Blue Fin Inn
Why Choose Us
Real Keys Charm
We’re one of the few truly local motels in Islamorada—no big chains here, just classic Old Florida hospitality and that relaxed, keezy vibe you came for.
Central Location
Steps away from restaurants, shops, marinas, and attractions. Whether you're heading out to fish or catch a sunset, everything’s around the corner.
No-Nonsense Comfort
Our rooms are simple, clean, and budget-friendly—perfect for travelers who care more about their adventures over extra bells and whistles.